Panic Attacks or Something Else? Exploring Sudden Anxiety with Anxiety & Trauma Therapy NYC

Panic can strike seemingly without warning and feel overwhelming. Anxiety Therapy NYC helps you understand what’s happening and how to find steady ground again.

Photo by Meghan Hessler; Uploaded from Unsplash on 5/16/25.

You’re walking down the street or trying to get through your workday when, suddenly, it hits: your heart is pounding, your chest tightens, your breath becomes shallow. Maybe you feel like you’re going to pass out—or like you might be dying. Minutes pass, maybe longer, and afterward you’re left shaky, exhausted, and wondering: What just happened to me?

If this sounds familiar, you may have experienced a panic attack. But that’s not the whole story. As a therapist who specializes in Anxiety Therapy NYC, I often help clients explore whether their panic is related to a diagnosable panic disorder, a form of generalized anxiety, or perhaps something trauma-related.

Understanding what you’re experiencing isn’t just about naming it—it’s about choosing the right path forward. Let’s walk through the possibilities together.

Panic Attack or High Anxiety?

Let’s start here: panic attacks are terrifying. Even when they’re not life-threatening, they often feel like they are. People describe them as moments where they genuinely believed they were dying, having a heart attack, or losing control.

But not every spike in anxiety is a panic attack. That’s why I’m always curious to learn what the experience was like for my clients. Was there a clear trigger? Was it out of the blue? How long did it last? How often does it happen? What have you tried to manage it so far?

Understanding the intensity, severity, and frequency is key. And so is validating that whatever you’re experiencing—it matters. You deserve support.

The Clinical Differentials: A Quick Breakdown

In therapy, I often explain it this way:

• Generalized Anxiety Disorder (GAD) is when your anxiety is persistent, often present in multiple areas of life, and includes symptoms like restlessness, tension, irritability, or trouble sleeping.

• Panic Attacks can occur as part of GAD, or on their own. They’re short bursts of intense fear or discomfort that peak within minutes.

• Panic Disorder is when panic attacks are recurrent and come with anticipatory anxiety—fear of having another attack, which starts to impact how you live your life.

• Trauma-Related Disorders (like PTSD or Complex PTSD) involve a history of overwhelming experiences where your body and mind believed you were in danger—or were in danger. When reminded of those experiences, your system may flood you with a panic-like response that mimics an attack, even if you’re not consciously aware of the memory.

This is where things get nuanced. Because trauma-related panic can feel exactly like a panic attack, but the underlying cause—and treatment direction—is different.

Trauma-Related Panic: What It Might Feel Like

Sometimes a client says, “I was fine—and then out of nowhere, I panicked.” But through mindful reflection and inquiry, we start to notice subtle cues: a sound, a tone of voice, a certain environment that reminded them of something their body hasn’t forgotten.

Trauma responses are rooted in the nervous system. And the hallmark of unresolved trauma is this: your body reacts as if the danger is happening now—even when it isn’t.

You might:

• Freeze and feel disconnected from your surroundings

• Feel a sudden sense of dread or nausea without knowing why

• Experience flashbacks, intense fear, or bodily sensations that don’t match the moment

Whether or not you remember the original trauma, your body does.

What We Do in the Beginning of Therapy

Skill-building starts gently—often with our younger, overwhelmed parts. Anxiety and Trauma Therapy in NYC supports you in rebuilding internal stability, block by block.

Photo by Markus Spiske; Uploaded from Unsplash on 5/16/2025.

Honestly, the early stages of treatment often look similar—no matter the cause of your panic. We start by:

• Building internal resources for grounding and emotional safety

• Practicing mindfulness to recognize and name your experience

• Developing regulation tools so panic doesn’t dominate your day

This isn’t just about symptom relief (though that matters). It’s about creating enough internal spaciousness to reflect and explore: Where is this coming from? What is my system trying to protect me from?

Over time, this helps us differentiate whether we’re dealing with trauma-based reactivity, general anxiety, or something more structured like panic disorder.

Where We Go Next (And How It Depends on the Root)

Once we’ve created enough safety, our treatment path can diverge based on the why behind your panic.

If it’s generalized anxiety or panic disorder:

• We work with the part of you that’s been “anxiety-ing” so hard

• We explore what protective role that anxious part is playing

• We use somatic, cognitive, and experiential techniques to shift your relationship to the fear and rewire the emotional learning beneath it

If it’s trauma-related panic:

• We do all of the above, plus we go deeper

• I use EMDR Therapy to reprocess the traumatic memories and reduce your nervous system’s sensitivity to reminders

• We work on desensitizing the memory networks, so they no longer send you back into the past when triggered

In both cases, therapy becomes a space to unburden your system—to teach your nervous system that you don’t have to work so hard to be safe anymore.

A Reassuring Frame: Your System Is Doing Its Job

Your nervous system isn’t broken—it’s working overtime. Anxiety and Trauma Counseling in NYC helps it do less protecting and more resting.

Photo by Resume Genius; Uploaded from Unsplash on 5/16/2025.

One thing I tell every client who’s panicked is this: your nervous system is working perfectly. It just might be working too hard.

You’re not broken. You’re not weak. You’re not being dramatic.

Your system is trying to protect you. The work we do in Anxiety and Trauma Therapy in NYC is about giving that system new tools—ones that don’t rely on fear, shutdown, or avoidance to keep you safe.

We help your body feel what safety actually is. And we give your mind a break from trying to think its way out of panic.

What If You’re Still Not Sure What’s Going On?

That’s okay. You don’t need a definitive label before seeking support.

If you:

• Are experiencing sudden, intense anxiety that’s affecting your life

• Feel like your body is reacting faster than your thoughts

• Worry you might “lose control” or “go crazy” when panic strikes

• Are stuck in a cycle of fear and avoidance

…you don’t have to navigate that alone.

Let’s explore what your symptoms might be trying to tell you—and how we can help you move through them with clarity, confidence, and care.

Reach out below for a free 15-minute consultation and let’s talk about how Anxiety Therapy NYC can help you move out of panic and into peace.